Grand Theft Auto VI (Rockstar Games, 2026) has released and to no one’s surprise, the game is currently dominating the news whether that is because it was nominated for awards before even being released, it has been aggregated as the greatest video game of all time on Metacritic, or because Rockstar’s employees are calling for the need to establish a union. My own interest in GTA VI lies in the praise of the game’s portrayal of romance and depiction of pornography. It seems that GTA, a series which has previously stoked moral outrage for its sexual content, now finds itself universally celebrated as a mature work of art in part for the two reasons above. Writing for The New York Times, Yussef Cole praises GTA VI for its characterization of the romance between its two main characters Jason and Lucia:
Instead of doing doughnuts in the middle of intersections or getting into fistfights with passers-by, Jason can opt to fix up his run-down bachelor pad in preparation for Lucia’s imminent release. There are numerous tasks around the house, like putting up drywall, painting and fixing the roof, that take up the player’s time and the character’s in-game resources, but they aim toward a productive and satisfying goal: a better relationship. This reflects a maturation of a series that has generally only told stories about men solipsistically chasing after their own success. Here, whether you’re controlling Jason or, eventually, Lucia, much of what you can do — apart from activities routine to G.T.A. like stealing cars and robbing banks — is taking action to care for and nurture your romantic partner.1
Cole later concludes:
Partway through the game, Lucia and Jason take a walk down their hotel’s sandy-white beach. They, naturally, lock hands. The foaming surf laps at their feet with hyper-realistic verisimilitude. Above is not just a skybox, but fluffy cumulus clouds hanging in volumetric space. There’s nothing to do here. The gunfights and car chases and cartoonish gangster shenanigans can wait. They’re distractions from the game’s true achievement: the well-earned satisfaction of an authentic human bond.2
Reviewing the game for The Guardian, Keza MacDonald touched upon the GTA VI’s 18-rating and expressed sentiments similar to Cole, writing, “A game this huge can accommodate both pathos and lewdness, and much more.”3 In Kotaku, Zack Zwiezen followed suit:
One time while I was playing as Jason, after spending all day and most of the night with Lucia, we came home, and I couldn’t even get through the door before both of them were on top of each other. If you were wondering: Jason and Lucia fuck a lot in this game, assuming you play them as a couple, which I did. It didn’t take long for me to fall in love with Jason and Lucia.4
What matters here is less that GTA VI has earned acclaim and more that GTA VI has been given an affordance long withheld from Japanese video games. For at least two decades now, within the Anglsophere, Japanese games have bore the brunt of being labeled as vulgar pornography, policed, and poorly ridiculed. Take for example issue 232 of Electronic Gaming Monthly which features a review of the Japanese airsoft simulation game, Simple 2000 Series Vol. 119 – The Survival Game 2 (Bestmedia, 2007). The review opens, “We used to think Japan wasn’t capable of creating anything that’s not smut. I guess we were wrong. Sure, the Land of the Rising Sun is home to screaming porn stars, anatomically correct anime toys, and game-inspired nudie flicks…”4 In a special issue dedicated to the state of the Japanese games industry, another article took aim at the genre of Japanese dating-sims, describing them as, “These games are like doing your taxes while poking at your girlfriend with a stick and hoping for the best.”5 Some might counter that I am perhaps taking too seriously the irreverent style of writing that was so prevalent of the time but the back-handed discussion of Japanese games was far from an issue isolated to only a handful of years. Even GameFan which later prided itself on the coverage of otaku culture had to apologize in 1995 after sending to print a review of College Football USA ’96 (High Score Entertainment, 1995) which seemed to instead contain text for a review of Ace Combat (Namco, 1995) where the reviewer wrote, “I think those little jap bastards love to freak, no i take that back I know those little jap bastards love to freak on military Sims…”6 According to GameFan, this was merely filler text that somehow made it beyond publication but the point across these examples still stands. The Japanese games industry and its fanbase could be ridiculed while magazines also benefitted from covering these same topics. I suggest that even while sentiments have improved, what we can understand as “bishōjo” games are at least still subjected to discriminatory practices which has elided Western games with GTA VI only being the most recent example.


Electronic Gaming Monthly, No. 232 (September 2008)
The consequences of such attitudes are not abstract but rather have had a concrete and lasting impact on the reception and discussion of bishōjo games in the West. For one, it is partially the reason why so many foundational titles, which are critical to the history of Japanese games, were never released abroad. These were games which were perceived as being a mix of too strange and too niche. In other words, unmarketable. Princess Maker (Gainax, 1991) may have received an official English release but it took decades whereas Tokimeki Memorial (Konami, 1994) and Sakura Wars (Red Company, Sega, 1996) were instead translated by fans only in more recent years. Whether they are dating-sims or actual erogē, as I have pointed out in my literature review of the academic article “Dating Simulation Games,” the lack of releases threatens to warp our understanding of the wider genre and subsequently video game history.
While Western games were eventually seen as maturing, Japanese games remained absent from similar discussion. In 2017, Game Informer published the article, “Digital Intimacy: How recent video games are tackling sexuality,” where the author Elise Favis suggests that as sex has become more common in video games, a few titles are working towards more complex depictions of sex, including Dragon Age: Inquisition (BioWare, 2014), The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt (CD Projekt Red, 2015) and Ladykiller in a Bind (Love Conquers All Games, 2016).7 Favis ultimately sees video games as progressively improving their depictions of sex as the medium ages, noting, “Video games are still in their infancy in comparison to other media, meaning missteps are common and inclusive representations remain slim.”8 Certainly, while video games are younger than cinema and literature, sex had long been part of games, especially in Japan with earlier titles, such as Tokyo Nanpa Street (Enix, 1985) and Can Can Bunny (Cocktail Soft, 1989) incorporating sex into their structure. Of course, there were games such as Tenshi-tachi no Gogo (Jast, 1985) where the depictions of sex were lurid and gross but as per Favis’ own argument, as the erogē genre further developed, so too did the depictions of sex become more complex (although the depiction of non-heterosexual sex remained scarce). Character writing improved with the landmark Dōkyūsei (ELF, 1992) and became the staple of the genre with To Heart (Leaf, 1997). Other games such as Love Escalator (Umitsuki Production, 1998) and its remake Lovers ~ Koi ni Ochitara…~ (Jellyfish, 2003) emphasized the importance of consent in their sexual mechanics.9

Some may argue that I am using GTA VI to battle an imaginary enemy that no longer exists but how much has the perception of Japanese games really improved? While Steam has allowed erogē to finally establish a market abroad, the platform has also made it difficult for Japanese games to be included on its storefront. Developer Viv’s boys love visual novel, This Game is Not Real, failed to meet Steam’s rather nebulous criteria for approval; Hyogo Onimushi’s all-ages mystery adventure game, Return to Zeroes had its initial demo rejected; and, in a maneuver that has long become the norm, Sengoku Rance was recently published on Steam censored, transforming Rance into someone that just really likes kissing. Of course, the uncensored patch can be readily found online but this particular issue disproportionately affects Japanese games. Elsewhere, payment processors have pressured platforms where adult content can be purchased. Back in April 2024, Eisys—the parent company of DLsite—announced that they were suspending the usage of Visa and Mastercard.10 Subsequently, in October 2025, viviON partnered with the Japanese domestic bank Minna no Ginko to launch their own proprietary payment service, Minna no Ginko Payment.11 Earlier this July, Japanese independent and adult game developer Nupuryu announced that Rakuten Bank had blocked revenue earned on Steam which originated overseas.
Despite also being pornographic, GTA VI is subjected to none of these same issues and instead the game is readily advertised everywhere, including Discord’s home screen, and accessible. What we have is a scenario not too dissimilar from Sandfall Interactive’s Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 (2025) in that GTA’s Western origins, vast financial backing, and verisimilitude means that it is all the more easily accepted when compared to Japanese games. The former is touted. The latter rejected, misrepresented, and forgotten.

- Yussef Cole, “Grand Theft Auto VI Will Steal Your Heart,” The New York Times, November 18, 2026, https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/18/arts/grand-theft-auto-vi-review.html. ↩︎
- Yussef Cole, “Grand Theft Auto VI Will Steal Your Heart.” ↩︎
- Keza MacDonald, “Grand Theft Auto VI review – gaming’s most depraved world is now also its greatest love story,” The Guardian, November 18, 2026, https://www.theguardian.com/games/2026/nov/18/grand-theft-auto-vi-gta-6-review-playstation-rockstar ↩︎
- Electronic Gaming Monthly, No. 219 (September 2007), p.18. ↩︎
- Sean Patrick Reiley, Electronic Gaming Monthly, No. 232 (September 2008), p.90. ↩︎
- Diehard GameFan, Vol. 3, No.9 (September 1995) ↩︎
- Elise Favis, “Digital Intimacy: How Recent Video Games Tackle Sexuality,” Game Informer, November 23, 2017, https://gameinformer.com/b/features/archive/2017/11/23/digital-intimacy-how-recent-video-games-tackle-sexuality ↩︎
- Elise Favis, “Digital Intimacy: How Recent Video Games Tackle Sexuality.” ↩︎
- There is an irony here in that as a certain subset of bishōjo games grew in either narrative or mechanical complexity, they could afford to censor or omit their more pornographic elements—the Sega Saturn of Yu-No (ELF, 1997) and the PlayStation version of ToHeart (Leaf, 1999) being prime examples. Regarding the Sega Saturn, erogē and dating-sims composed some of the console’s best-selling titles. In other words, while these genres first remained absent in North America, they were thriving in Japan.
↩︎ - Eisys, “[Important] To our cusotmers using Visa and Mastercard [April 4th Update],” Eisys, April 3, 2024, https://info.eisys.co.jp/dlsite/69dd17c1c4b21c06?locale=en_US ↩︎
- Eisys, “【重要】「みんなの銀行決済」の提供開始とスタートキャンペーン開催のお知らせ,” Eisys, October 6, 2025, https://info.eisys.co.jp/dlsite/69dd17c1c4b21c06 ↩︎